Can A Woman Suffering from Cancer Be Fired for Refusing Overtime: no simple answer

Question:

When I told my manager I had cancer, she was initially supportive and asked a lot of personal questions, which I foolishly answered.

Since then, she’s become increasingly critical of my work performance in areas that she used to call “not a problem.” Our worst fights occur when she asks me to continue working on projects after the normal workday ends.

In the past I’ve been willing to work into the evening and on weekends to finish a project, but now I just can’t. I need my rest.

She’s pointed out that she and everyone work overtime during peak workloads and has pulled out my job application, filled out more than three years ago, in which I wrote “of course” when asked if I was willing to work overtime.

And I’m willing, but just not able. I’m scared I’m going to get fired over this and won’t be able to get a new job because chemotherapy is making me lose my hair and it will be impossible to hide my cancer.

Can she fire me for refusing to work overtime when I have cancer and need my rest?

Answer:

You need an attorney or someone from your state’s human rights commission to look at your job description and this situation. Your answer depends on whether overtime is an essential function of your job and whether your supervisor intentionally discriminates against you due to your cancer.

The Americans with Disabilities Act protects employees and applicants with cancer if their employers discriminate against them due to their cancer and if the employee can accomplish the essential functions of their job with or without reasonable accommodation.

A reduced work schedule might be a reasonable accommodation, as might your employer temporarily transferring some of your job duties to others. These options depend on your job and on whether overtime is an essential function. Here are four real-life situations where overtime has been found to be an essential function:

When systems engineer Thomas Davis sued Microsoft Corporation, alleging his company should have altered his job duties to accommodate his disability, a hepatitis C infection that prevented him from working more than eight hours a day or 40 hours a week, Microsoft countered that Davis needed to respond to urgent, unpredictable customer problems and had regularly worked long days. In that lawsuit, Davis v. Microsoft Corporation, a court ruled that working overtime was an essential function of a systems engineer’s job.

In another case, Manigan v. Southwest Ohio Regional Transit Authority, a court ruled that a bus driver needed to be able to drive more than eight hours in a shift and thus the ability to work overtime was an essential job function.

In Davis v. Florida Power & Light Co.¸ a court ruled that the utility needed employees who could work overtime in jobs that involved reconnecting electric power service given the customer need for same day reconnection and noted that employees regularly worked overtime and this requirement was noted on the employment application.

Finally, can you prove a linkage to your supervisor’s desire that you work long hours and her criticisms of situations she formerly defined as “no problem.” If so, you might have de facto evidence that her treatment of you changed with your cancer diagnosis and your related inability to work overtime.   

Subscribing to the blog is easy

If you’d like to get 3 to 5 posts a week delivered to your inbox (and NO spam), just add your email address below. (I’ll never sell it.) I’m glad you’ve joined this vibrant blog. Thank you!

3 thoughts on “Can A Woman Suffering from Cancer Be Fired for Refusing Overtime: no simple answer

  1. This situation makes me sad. It’s not about what’s legal in this instance, but rather what’s right. The fact that her employer is unwilling to make accommodations to a loyal employee while they getting treatment for cancer is incomprehensible. I hope when she is well that she finds an employer that deserves her.

  2. Agree, someone fighting cancer shouldn’t have to fight her employer as well. At the same time, there are jobs that require OT.

  3. As your answer shows, a complicated series of questions, tests, documentation, and situations make it depend on the circumstances. Wow. Thanks for sharing these examples.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.