Worn out. Skeptical. Disengaged.

If those words fit you, your co-workers, or employees, you’re not alone. As fully outlined in my March 30th, “No Love Lost” post, https://workplacecoachblog.com/2021/03/no-love-lost-employees-leaving-their-jobs-in-record-numbers/mentioned last week, between twenty-five and fifty percent of all employees plan to leave their current employers in 2021.1, 2

Worn out. Skeptical. Disengaged.

If those words fit you or the employees you supervise, you have company. Employees in many workplaces have lost trust in their employers. According to the Edelman Trust Barometer, one in three of the 33,000 employees surveyed don’t trust their employer, with the distrust percentage growing the lower one travels in the organization.1 This distrust eats away at employee morale and commitment, saps employee performance, and drains an organization’s productivity.  

Want proof? The Center for Neuroeconomics Studies gathered data from a dozen employers that launched policy and other changes designed to raise trust. Employees that worked for employers in that scored in the top quartile for trust reported that they were 76% more engaged at work, 50% more productive and had 106% more energy than those whose employers scored in the bottom quartile.2,3

Further, 60% of employees that worked for high-trust employers enjoyed their jobs more, felt 70% more aligned with their organization’s purpose, and 50% planned to remain with their employer in the next year.3 Corroborating this, the Trust Edge Leadership Institute’s most recent research noted that 21% of 1202 working-age adults surveyed reported willingness to work longer hours if they trusted their organization’s leadership. A full one-third said they would stay longer with an employer whose leaders kept their promises.4

How COVID impacted trust

As you might expect, COVID has impacted employer/employee trust. Virtual workplace and physical distancing make it harder for managers and supervisors to connect with employees, and for employees to meaningfully interact with their coworkers.

The pandemic also created organizational and emotional chaos, pulling the rug out from under employers and employees alike. Many employees tumbled helplessly off their career paths, not knowing where or when they’d reach the bottom.

It wasn’t just the downsizing, restructuring and layoffs that led employees to feel distrustful. It was how their employer’s leaders managed these changes, often by holding information close to their vest and only announcing layoffs and furloughs the day the axe fell.  

Worse, many employers failed to acknowledge the human cost of their decisions, and didn’t support those furloughed, laid off, or even those retained. Employers seemed to expect employee survivors to behave as if the changes hadn’t happened and to focus on getting their jobs done, while they sandwiched in their departed colleagues’ duties. Column readers who called me in the last year made statements such as “I gave my best to this company and this is my reward?” and “I’m expected to handle a double workload. I’m taken advantage of, while my CEO gets a huge bonus.”  

Here’s what employers need to realize but often don’t: When employees learn that their company’s leaders don’t keep employee interests in mind as they make decisions, it sucks productive energy from employees. They worry whether they will have their jobs a month from now. Employee engagement and commitment plummet. Morale suffers.

Employees feel it’s every person for themselves and could care less about going above and beyond. They grow hesitant to take extra risks, fearing that their managers won’t back them up if the risk doesn’t pay off. They fear sharing bad news and withhold information, leaving problems to fester. Employees question their employer’s decisions and actions. They protect their self-interest at the expense of their company. They quit.

Trust is the adhesive that holds employees to an organization. When employees trust their company’s leaders, they can focus on doing their jobs. What happens was trust goes missing? Productivity follows.

Monday’s post, from a young fast-food restaurant worker, shows how a manager’s actions break trust with employees.

You might find interesting tomorrow’s post on how employees can sleuth out employers they can trust, https://workplacecoachblog.com/2021/04/how-employees-can-find-employers-they-trust/

Next Tuesday’s article focuses on how employers can earn back employees’ trust.

1https://www.td.org/insights/5-steps-for-fuilding-trust-in-the-workplace

2https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbeshumanresourcescouncil/2020/09/18/three-ways-to-cultivate-a-high-trust-culture-in-a-remote-workforce/?sh=4cb01f4d761e

3https://hbr.org/2017/01/the-neuroscience-of-trust

4https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/0618/pages/why-trust-matters-at-work.aspx

Subscribing to the blog is easy

If you’d like to get 3 to 5 posts a week delivered to your inbox (and NO spam), just add your email address below. (I’ll never sell it.) I’m glad you’ve joined this vibrant blog. Thank you!

5 thoughts on “Worn out. Skeptical. Disengaged.

  1. Although the pandemic created these problems on a much larger scale and affected more people this same dynamic has been in place for many years. Downsizing has been a practice companies have been using regularly since the 1970’s. The WARN act requires more advance notice of layoffs in some circumstances, but much of the time this does not apply, and employees are let go with no warning, the surviving employees have to pick up the work, and trust is destroyed. I experienced this in the 80’s, the 90’s, and just did again (twice in the last year). I was also in the place of having to carry out downsizing before. I have experienced the changes you write about as a survivor of layoffs as well a few times.

  2. My thought was just as the pandemic exposed long-time systematic lacks and built-in racism and other shortcomings in many of our work arrangements and social assumptions. so it has shown some of the worn-out empty really bad parts of working and of employers’ lack of follow-through. genuine communication, etc. This post says it!

    1. Susan, well said. The pandemic exposed under-the-surface problems. I agree with your comments as well as with Dee’s earlier comments.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *